The Beit Midrash Hotline

Fast, considered answers

You have a question. A rabbi has an answer.

Send it in your own words. A rabbi who knows that area reads it and writes back — a real person, not a search result.

Free. In Hebrew, English, Russian, Spanish or French.

By sending a question you agree to it being processed so that a rabbi can answer you. Your contact details are never shown to the rabbi; they are held by the platform's operator, RAU University. How we handle your data.

Question № 00412

Asked from São Paulo · WhatsApp

I'm learning Bava Metzia 21b in daf yomi. Rashi and Tosafot seem to read the same case in opposite directions. Am I missing something, or is this a real disagreement?

Answered by a rabbi · six hours later

You are not missing anything — this is a real disagreement, and it turns on what despair of recovery means. Rashi reads it as a state of mind the owner has already reached; Tosafot read it as one the law assumes he will reach…

See also: Bava Metzia 22b, and the Rosh there.

Answered in six hours The rabbi never sees your number, and you never see his

Ways to reach us

Three ways to ask

Use whichever you already have open. Photos of a page, voice notes and scans are all fine — we read them.

+972 2 380 3613

Text or voice note. Answers come back to the same chat, from our number — never from the rabbi's own phone.

Email

ask@ibmtorah.org

Write as you would to a friend. Attach a photo of the page if that's easier than typing the passage.

Phone

Opening soon

Ask out loud and get a call back. Both numbers stay hidden: ours is the only one either side sees.

The process

What happens after you send it

Four steps, and only the last one involves you again.

You write, in your own language

No form, no account, no subject line to get right. The question can be half-formed — that is what a beit midrash is for.

It reaches a rabbi who knows the area

Tractate, subject and language are read from the question itself and matched against what each rabbi has taken on — a specific masechta, a field of study, or general questions.

He answers from his own desk

The rabbi replies from his own mailbox, the way he answers anyone. There is no interface for him to learn and nothing to log into.

The answer comes back to you

On the same channel you wrote from, usually within twelve working hours. If it takes longer, the question moves to another rabbi rather than waiting.

Scope of answers

What we answer — and what we don't

Being clear about the second half is what makes the first half worth trusting.

Bring us these

Gemara and its commentaries — a sugya that won't come together
Mishna, Tanach, Midrash, and the words themselves
Halacha as study: why the law is what it is
Machshava and emunah — the questions people are shy to ask aloud
Mussar, tefilla, the weekly parasha, today's daf
Minhagim: where a custom came from and why communities differ

Not these

A practical ruling for your own situation right now
“Is this pot kosher after what I just did to it?”
Anything where the answer decides what you do in the next hour

A psak needs a rav who knows you, your community and the full circumstances — over a message that is guesswork. Ask your own rav, or the local beit horaa. If your question was really a study question wearing practical clothes, rephrase it and send it back to us.

Our commitment

Three things we hold to

12h

An answer, or a different rabbi

Twelve working hours is the target. A question that goes unanswered moves on rather than going quiet.

Contact details exchanged between you and the rabbi

You never see the rabbi's number, and he never sees yours. Everything passes through the platform — by design, not by policy. The platform's operator, RAU University, does hold your details; what it may do with them.

Shabbat is not a deadline

Questions arrive at any hour, but no rabbi is notified on Shabbat or yom tov in his own timezone — and that time doesn't count against the answer.

For rabbis

If you are the one who can answer

Take a masechta, a subject, or general questions — and say how many you want a week. Nothing arrives on Shabbat or yom tov, and you answer from your own mailbox with nothing new to learn.

Join as a rabbi